Kajabi vs Teachable vs Thinkific: We Found the Best Platform

Kajabi vs Teachable vs Thinkific

Kajabi, Teachable, and Thinkific are three of the biggest names in online course platforms, but they solve different problems: Kajabi is best for creators who want an all-in-one business system, Teachable is best for launching and selling courses quickly, and Thinkific is best for structured course delivery with flexible learning features.

Kajabi has the strongest edge for marketers, agencies, coaches, and digital-product sellers because it combines courses, email marketing, funnels, landing pages, checkout, CRM, and AI business-building tools in one platform.

Bottom line: choose Kajabi if you want one platform to run your full knowledge-commerce business, choose Teachable if you want a simple course-selling platform with fast setup, and choose Thinkific if your priority is course structure, student experience, and lower entry pricing.

Kajabi vs Teachable vs Thinkific: Quick Verdict

Kajabi Logo

Kajabi is the best choice for creators who care about marketing, funnels, automation, email, premium offers, coaching, memberships, and business growth in one dashboard.

It costs more, but it can replace several tools that course creators usually buy separately, including landing-page software, email marketing software, funnel software, checkout tools, and basic CRM workflows.

Thinkific Logo

Thinkific is the best choice for educators, training businesses, and creators who care more about course structure, communities, learning paths, and student engagement than advanced funnel marketing.

Its pricing page highlights unlimited courses, video lessons, quizzes, student discussions, communities, digital downloads, coaching, webinars, and paid memberships depending on plan.

Teachable logo

Teachable is the best choice for beginners and solo creators who want to launch a course without overthinking systems.

Its current pricing page shows plans with AI creation tools, iOS and Android student apps, global payments and taxes, upsells, cart recovery, and course certificates included across plans.

MAGIC10 Get 10% OFF
PlatformMain strengthMain weakness
KajabiFull business system with email, funnels, CRM, courses, checkout, and AI CofounderExpensive for beginners
TeachableFast setup, simple selling, AI creation, global payments, appsLess powerful for advanced funnels and native marketing
ThinkificStrong course delivery, communities, unlimited courses, branded app optionNeeds more third-party tools for full marketing stack

What are These Platforms?

Kajabi

Kajabi is a business operating system for selling expertise online. It lets you build courses, coaching products, landing pages, email sequences, sales funnels, checkout flows, automations, and business assets with its AI Cofounder.

Teachable

Teachable is a course and digital-product platform designed to help creators sell online products quickly. Its pricing page positions plans around launching, selling, and scaling an online business with AI creation, global payments, student apps, upsells, cart recovery, and course certificates.

Thinkific

Thinkific is a course platform focused on building, selling, and delivering learning products. Its pricing page emphasizes unlimited courses, video lessons, quizzes, student discussions, communities, coaching, webinars, landing pages, and digital downloads depending on plan.

Our honest view: Kajabi is the strongest if your business is marketing-led, Teachable is the fastest if your business is creator-led, and Thinkific is the most education-led. That difference matters because a course creator selling a $49 mini-course does not need the same platform as an agency selling a $2,000 coaching program.

Kajabi, Teachable, Thinkific Features Compared

Here is the high-level comparison before we go deeper into every category.

FeatureKajabiTeachableThinkific
Course builderStrong, polished, premium deliveryVery easy and beginner-friendlyStrong structure and learning features
PricingPremiumMid-rangeLower entry pricing
Email marketingStrong native email and automationBasic creator messaging and sales toolsMore limited; often needs integrations
Sales funnelsStrong native funnel systemBasic upsells and cart recoveryMore basic funnel tools
SEOGood for sales pages and creator sitesGood for course sales pagesGood for course websites
CommunityBuilt into creator ecosystemIncluded in new plan structureStrong community products and spaces
AnalyticsGood revenue and marketing visibilityGood sales/student reporting on higher plansGood learning and student progress reporting
Mobile appKajabi app ecosystemiOS and Android student appsThinkific Mobile and branded app option
IntegrationsGood, but fewer neededGood external ecosystemStrong app marketplace-style use case
PaymentsStrong for digital offersGlobal payments and taxesTCommerce and Stripe-related options
Free trialKajabi trial and promo offers7-day free trial and 30-day guaranteeTrial availability from Thinkific sign-up flow
AICofounder for offers, pages, emails, launch assetsCreate with AIAI-assisted course/product creation features reported in comparisons

Pricing Comparison

Pricing is where the three platforms split sharply. Kajabi is the most expensive, Teachable sits in the middle, and Thinkific has the lowest entry price among the three.

Kajabi Pricing Plans

Kajabi's pricing page lists Basic at $199/month monthly or $143/month annually, Growth at $249/month monthly or $199/month annually, and Pro at $499/month monthly or $399/month annually. Kajabi also went through a major 2026 pricing update, and its official update page says pricing changes for existing customers took effect on January 13, 2026.

Teachable's pricing page lists Starter at $39/month monthly or $29/month annually, Builder at $89/month monthly or $69/month annually, and Growth at $189/month monthly or $139/month annually, with a 7-day free trial and 30-day guarantee shown on the annual plan section. Teachable's support documentation says the Starter plan has a 7.5% base transaction fee, while Builder, Growth, and Advanced have 0% base transaction fees.

Thinkific's pricing page lists Basic at $49/month monthly or $36/month annually and includes unlimited courses, video lessons, quizzes, student discussions, and one community on Basic.

Third-party 2026 pricing coverage reports Thinkific's standard plans as Basic at $49/month monthly or $36/month annually, Start at $99/month monthly or $74/month annually, and Grow at $199/month monthly or $149/month annually.

PlatformEntry paid planMid planHigher planTransaction fee notes
KajabiBasic from $199/month monthly or $143/month annualGrowth from $249/month monthly or $199/month annualPro from $499/month monthly or $399/month annualKajabi positions pricing with no revenue sharing
TeachableStarter from $39/month monthly or $29/month annualBuilder from $89/month monthly or $69/month annualGrowth from $189/month monthly or $139/month annualStarter has 7.5% base transaction fee; Builder and above have 0% base transaction fees
ThinkificBasic from $49/month monthly or $36/month annualStart reported from $99/month monthly or $74/month annualGrow reported from $199/month monthly or $149/month annualThird-party 2026 analysis reports Stripe surcharge differences depending on processor and plan

Verdict: Thinkific wins on low entry cost, Teachable wins for affordable course selling with stronger commerce features, and Kajabi wins if you calculate total stack replacement.

For agencies and serious marketers, Kajabi's monthly price is easier to justify because it can reduce the need for multiple external tools.

Course Builder

All three platforms can host and sell online courses, but their course builders feel different. Kajabi is polished and business-oriented, Teachable is simple and fast, and Thinkific is more structured for learning design.

Kajabi is strong when the course is part of a bigger offer, such as a coaching program, membership, funnel, or premium digital product. Kajabi's own comparison content describes it as a platform where courses sit alongside websites, email campaigns, sales funnels, coaching products, and automations.

Teachable is easier for first-time creators because the setup flow is direct. Search results and comparisons repeatedly describe Teachable as simple, straightforward, and built for fast course creation.

Thinkific has the edge for course structure and learning flexibility. Its pricing page mentions unlimited courses, video lessons, quizzes, student discussions, communities, digital downloads, coaching, webinars, and paid memberships depending on plan.

Course featureKajabiTeachableThinkific
Beginner setupGoodBestGood
Course structureGoodGoodStrong
Learning toolsGoodGoodStrong
Premium course experienceStrongGoodGood
Coaching + course bundleStrongGoodGood
Best fitPremium offer creatorsFirst-time course sellersEducators and academies

Verdict: Teachable is easiest, Thinkific is strongest for structured learning, and Kajabi is best when the course is only one part of a larger monetization funnel.

Email Marketing

Email marketing is one of the biggest reasons creators choose Kajabi. Kajabi includes native email marketing with broadcasts, automated sequences, visual automation builders, behavior-based branching, tagging, and segmentation.

Teachable includes creator sales tools, but it is not as deep as Kajabi for advanced email automation. Teachable's pricing page highlights upsells, cart recovery, AI creation, global payments, and student apps, but advanced marketing workflows usually still push serious creators toward dedicated email tools.

Thinkific is more course-first than email-first. It can support selling and student communication, but creators who need advanced launches, segmentation, behavioral automation, and evergreen funnels usually connect Thinkific with external tools.

Email featureKajabiTeachableThinkific
Broadcast emailsYesYes/basicLimited/basic
Automated sequencesStrongBasic compared with KajabiUsually needs integrations
SegmentationStrongBasicBasic
Behavioral automationStrongLimitedLimited
Best for launchesStrongModerateModerate with integrations

Verdict: Kajabi clearly wins email marketing. If email drives your launches, upsells, onboarding, and retention, Kajabi gives you the cleanest native system.

Sales Funnels

Kajabi has the strongest funnel system because landing pages, forms, offers, checkout, emails, automations, and products can live inside one flow. Kajabi's own 2026 comparison content says users can create a landing page, build an email sequence, connect it to a product, and launch a funnel inside Kajabi.

Teachable gives you practical commerce tools such as upsells and cart recovery. Its pricing page lists upsells and cart recovery across plans, which makes it useful for simple sales optimization.

Thinkific can sell courses, memberships, digital downloads, coaching, and webinars, but it is not as funnel-native as Kajabi. Its strengths are product delivery and learning experience rather than full-funnel marketing.

Funnel featureKajabiTeachableThinkific
Landing pagesStrongBasic/goodGood
Email sequence connectionStrongBasicNeeds external support
UpsellsStrongYesAvailable depending setup
Cart recoveryStrongYesMore limited
Evergreen funnelsStrongLimitedNeeds integrations

Verdict: Kajabi wins for sales funnels. Teachable is good enough for simple course sales, while Thinkific works better when paired with external funnel tools.

SEO and Website Builder

Kajabi, Teachable, and Thinkific can all create course websites and sales pages, but none of them replaces WordPress for a large SEO publishing operation. WordPress still makes more sense for heavy content, programmatic SEO, advanced schema, and deep editorial control.

Kajabi's advantage is that its website builder connects directly to the business system. You can create landing pages, sales pages, funnels, emails, checkout pages, and product access inside one platform.

Teachable is better for simple creator storefronts and product sales pages. It is not built to replace a full CMS, but it gives creators enough control to launch and sell without technical setup.

Thinkific is good for branded school websites, course landing pages, and academy-style presentation. Its pricing page includes site builder and landing-page features in its plan comparison.

SEO/site featureKajabiTeachableThinkific
Course sales pagesStrongGoodGood
Full website builderStrongModerateGood
Blog/content SEOBasic to moderateBasicBasic to moderate
Best for affiliate SEO siteNot idealNot idealNot ideal
Best for sales pagesStrongGoodGood

Verdict: Kajabi wins for conversion-focused pages, Thinkific is good for academy-style pages, and Teachable is good for simple product storefronts. For serious SEO publishing, use WordPress and link to your course platform.

Community Features

Community is now a major part of course monetization because creators are selling access, accountability, and ongoing engagement, not just videos. Kajabi, Teachable, and Thinkific all support community in different ways.

Kajabi's community advantage is its connection to the broader creator business stack. Community can sit beside courses, coaching, email, offers, and funnels, which is useful for memberships and high-ticket programs.

Teachable's support documentation for new plans says community is included with unlimited spaces in the updated plan structure. That makes Teachable stronger than older reviews suggest, especially for creators who want a simple community attached to their products.

Thinkific has a very strong community angle. Its pricing page lists one community on Basic, one on Start, three on Grow, and unlimited communities on Plus, plus spaces, live events, and community-course bundling depending on plan.

Community featureKajabiTeachableThinkific
Built-in communityYesYesYes
Spaces/topicsYesUnlimited spaces noted in support docsSpaces vary by plan
Membership use caseStrongGoodStrong
Best for cohort engagementStrongGoodStrong
Best for all-in-one monetizationStrongModerateModerate

Verdict: Thinkific and Kajabi are strongest for communities, but for different reasons. Thinkific is strong for structured learning communities, while Kajabi is stronger when community is tied to funnels, coaching, email, and upsells.

Analytics and Reporting

Analytics matter because course creators need to know what is selling, where students drop off, and which products produce the best revenue. Kajabi gives marketers a better business-level view, while Thinkific tends to be stronger for learning progress and Teachable gives practical sales and student reporting.

Kajabi's 2026 review coverage notes that recent Kajabi updates improved builder UI and added 10+ revenue and performance reports. That matters for agencies and marketers who need to track revenue, campaigns, and product performance.

Teachable's pricing update content mentions detailed student reporting, advanced reports, course certificates, enforced lesson compliance, and auto-graded quizzes as part of its creator engagement improvements. This makes it better for creators who want a simple view of students and sales.

Thinkific is a good fit for training businesses that care about student progress, course engagement, and academy management. Its learning-product focus makes reporting more education-oriented than funnel-oriented.

Analytics needKajabiTeachableThinkific
Revenue reportingStrongGoodGood
Student reportingGoodGoodStrong
Marketing analyticsStrongModerateModerate
Funnel performanceStrongLimited/moderateLimited
Best for agenciesStrongGoodGood

Verdict: Kajabi is best for marketing and revenue analytics, Thinkific is best for course engagement analytics, and Teachable is best for simple sales/student reporting.

Mobile App

Mobile access is no longer optional because many students consume lessons on phones. Teachable and Thinkific are especially clear about mobile apps in their current positioning.

Teachable Mobile App

Teachable includes iOS and Android student apps in its current pricing plans. This is a strong advantage for beginners because they do not need to buy a separate branded app add-on just to give students mobile access.

Thinkific offers Thinkific Mobile and a branded mobile app option. Thinkific's own comparison says Thinkific Mobile is included in Start plans and above, while Branded Mobile is priced at $199/month.

Thinkific's branded mobile app page says the Branded Mobile App is available as a $199/month add-on or included at no additional cost with select Thinkific Plus plans. This is useful for academies, influencers, and training brands that want their own white-label mobile experience.

Kajabi also has a mobile ecosystem, but its bigger advantage is business integration rather than app customization. For branded mobile ownership, Thinkific has the clearer dedicated mobile app offer.

Mobile featureKajabiTeachableThinkific
Student mobile accessYesiOS and Android appsThinkific Mobile on Start+
Branded appLimited compared with ThinkificNot the main focus$199/month add-on or Plus inclusion
Best for simple mobile learningGoodStrongStrong
Best for white-label appModerateModerateStrong

Verdict: Teachable is very good for included student app access, while Thinkific wins for branded mobile app strategy. Kajabi is still strong if your priority is business workflow over mobile branding.

Integrations

Kajabi reduces the need for integrations because it already includes website pages, funnels, checkout, email, automations, CRM-style contact management, and AI Cofounder. That is its main strategic value for creators tired of duct-taping systems together.

Teachable works well for creators who want a clean course platform and are comfortable connecting external tools. It is often easier than Kajabi for first-time setup, but advanced marketers may still add ConvertKit, ActiveCampaign, Zapier, analytics tools, or external landing pages.

Thinkific also works well with external stacks, especially for educators who already have a website, email platform, CRM, or marketing system. Thinkific's model is attractive when you want a strong learning platform but do not expect your course tool to run your full business.

Integration styleKajabiTeachableThinkific
Needs fewer toolsBestModerateModerate
Works with external stackGoodGoodGood
Best for custom marketing stackGoodGoodStrong
Best for all-in-one stackStrongModerateModerate

Verdict: Kajabi wins if you want fewer tools. Thinkific wins if you already have a mature stack and only need a strong course platform.

Payments and Checkout

Payments are a key difference because course creators need to sell globally, offer payment plans, recover abandoned carts, and handle taxes correctly. Teachable is strong for payment simplicity because its pricing page highlights global payments and taxes across plans.

Kajabi is strong for premium offers, payment plans, upsells, funnels, and connected checkout flows. Its advantage is not only accepting payments; it is connecting payments to access, emails, automations, customer tagging, and follow-up.

Thinkific supports selling courses and digital products through its commerce setup, but pricing research notes that real costs can vary depending on whether creators use Thinkific's native commerce options or their own Stripe setup. This matters if you are calculating margin on high-volume course sales.

Payment featureKajabiTeachableThinkific
Global course sellingStrongStrong global payments/taxesGood
Payment plansStrongGoodGood
UpsellsStrongIncluded in Teachable plansAvailable depending setup
Cart recoveryStrongIncluded in Teachable plansMore limited
Best checkout for marketersStrongGoodGood

Verdict: Kajabi wins for connected checkout and funnel monetization. Teachable wins for simple global selling, while Thinkific is solid but requires closer fee review.

Free Trials

Free trials matter because you should never choose a course platform only from comparison tables. You need to build one real product, one landing page, one checkout flow, and one email sequence before deciding.

Kajabi has standard trial options, and you can use Affinco's Kajabi link for a better starting offer. Use this link to claim your 30-day Kajabi free trial, or use this special offer to get Kajabi for 3 months for just $1.99.
Teachable's pricing page shows a 7-day free trial and a 30-day guarantee on its annual plan section. That gives beginners enough time to test the dashboard, upload a course outline, and review the sales flow.

Thinkific's branded mobile app page tells new customers to start a free trial before accessing the mobile app channel from the admin area. That confirms Thinkific still uses a trial-based onboarding flow for new customers.

PlatformTrial/deal
Kajabi30-day free trial or 3 months for $1.99 via Affinco links
Teachable7-day free trial and 30-day guarantee
ThinkificFree trial available through sign-up flow

Verdict: Kajabi's special 3-month offer is the best deal if you want enough time to build and launch properly. Teachable's trial is good for quick testing, while Thinkific's trial is useful for validating course structure.

AI Features

AI is becoming a major category in course platforms because creators need help with product ideas, lesson outlines, landing pages, email copy, quizzes, translations, and launch assets. Kajabi has the most business-focused AI positioning through Cofounder.

Kajabi Cofounder is described as an AI business-building assistant that helps clarify business direction, shape offers, and generate launch-ready content like products, landing pages, emails, and marketing assets. Kajabi's Cofounder product page also says it can draft emails and pages in your voice and provide copy recommendations based on what converts for expert businesses.

Teachable AI-Powered Features

Teachable includes “Create with AI” across its current pricing plans. This makes Teachable useful for beginners who want help creating a course faster without hiring a strategist.

Thinkific also has AI-assisted course-building capabilities according to 2026 comparison coverage, but its main identity remains structured course delivery and education products rather than AI-led business strategy.

AI featureKajabiTeachableThinkific
AI course creationYesYes, Create with AIYes/available in comparisons
AI landing page copyStrong via CofounderBasic/moderateBasic/moderate
AI email copyStrong via CofounderModerateModerate
AI business strategyStrongestLimitedLimited
Best AI use caseOffer + funnel + launchQuick course creationCourse-building support

Verdict: Kajabi wins AI for marketers because Cofounder is closer to a business assistant than just a course-outline generator. Teachable is strong for quick creation, while Thinkific is useful but less differentiated.

Best by Creator Type

Best for beginners

Teachable is the best starting point for most beginners because it is cheaper than Kajabi, easier to set up, and includes practical selling tools like AI creation, student apps, global payments, upsells, cart recovery, and course certificates. If you are launching your first paid course and do not want a heavy system, Teachable feels less intimidating.

Thinkific is also beginner-friendly if your first priority is course structure and student learning. Its Basic plan includes unlimited courses, video lessons, quizzes, student discussions, and one community, which is generous for educators starting out.

Kajabi is not the cheapest beginner option, but it can still make sense for beginners who already have an audience, agency clients, coaching offer, or high-ticket product. If you are starting from zero with no list and no offer, Kajabi may feel expensive before you can use its full power.

Beginner verdict: choose Teachable for easiest launch, Thinkific for structured education, and Kajabi only if you are serious about building a full business system from day one.

Best for scaling creators

Kajabi is the strongest platform for scaling creators because growth usually depends on funnels, email sequences, customer segmentation, upsells, landing pages, automations, and offer strategy. Kajabi includes a full email marketing system with automation, tagging, segmentation, and behavior-based workflows.

Teachable is good for scaling if your business is still simple and course-led. Its Builder and higher plans remove the 7.5% Starter transaction fee, and Teachable's support docs say Builder, Growth, and Advanced have 0% base transaction fees.

Thinkific is strong for scaling education businesses that want more products, communities, and learner engagement. Its pricing page shows increasing community capacity by plan, with one community on Basic and Start, three on Grow, and unlimited communities on Plus.

Scaling verdict: choose Kajabi if marketing and automation drive revenue, Teachable if you want a clean selling platform, and Thinkific if the learning experience is the product.

Best for agencies

Kajabi is the best fit for agencies that build and manage funnels, offers, coaching programs, memberships, and client education products. Agencies benefit from having pages, offers, email, automation, checkout, CRM-style contacts, and AI Cofounder in one place.

Teachable can work for agencies that serve creators who only need a course store. It is especially practical for simple course builds where the client wants to launch quickly and avoid a large monthly bill.

Thinkific is a strong agency option for training businesses, corporate learning, certification-style products, and academy brands. It is less attractive when the agency's main deliverable is funnel performance, lifecycle marketing, and upsell systems.

Agency verdict: Kajabi gets the edge for marketing agencies, Thinkific gets the edge for education/training agencies, and Teachable works best for lean creator builds.

Best for enterprise

Thinkific and Teachable both have clearer enterprise-style positioning than many people expect. Teachable's enterprise page mentions organization management, branding, SSO, admins, users, published courses, video storage, analytics, support, and pricing from $2/user per month.

Thinkific Plus is the natural fit for larger training companies that want more communities, branded mobile options, and scalable learning products. Thinkific's branded mobile app can also be included at no additional cost with select Thinkific Plus plans.

Kajabi can support established creator businesses and high-revenue expert brands, but it is not the first platform we would choose for complex corporate LMS needs. It is better for expert businesses than traditional enterprise learning departments.

Enterprise verdict: choose Thinkific or Teachable for training operations and Kajabi for expert-led businesses with premium offers and marketing-led revenue.

1st Pick
Kajabi Logo
Where Kajabi Wins

Kajabi wins when you want fewer tools and tighter business workflows. Its biggest advantage is that email, funnels, landing pages, checkout, products, customer data, automations, and AI assistance live together.
Kajabi also wins for premium creators selling courses plus coaching, memberships, communities, podcasts, digital downloads, and recurring offers. If you are selling a $999 course or a $3,000 coaching program, the platform cost is easier to absorb.

Our honest take: Kajabi is not “better” for everyone, but it is better for people who think like marketers. If your business depends on launch funnels, list building, segmentation, upsells, offer creation, and customer journeys, Kajabi gives you the strongest native setup.

2nd Pick
Teachable logo
Where Teachable Wins

Teachable wins on simplicity and speed. Its current plans include Create with AI, iOS and Android student apps, global payments and taxes, upsells, cart recovery, and course certificates, which gives new creators a strong starting kit.
Teachable is also more affordable than Kajabi at the entry and mid-level plan range. The Starter plan has a 7.5% transaction fee, but Builder and higher plans have 0% base transaction fees according to Teachable's support documentation.

Our honest take: Teachable is the platform we would recommend to creators who say, “I just want to sell my course without building a complicated funnel machine.” It is not as powerful as Kajabi, but that simplicity is exactly why many beginners like it.

3rd Pick
Thinkific Logo
Where Thinkific Wins

Thinkific wins when education structure matters more than funnel complexity. Its Basic plan includes unlimited courses, video lessons, quizzes, student discussions, and one community, which is strong for course creators who care about learning design.
Thinkific also has a stronger branded mobile app story than the other two platforms. Its Branded Mobile App costs $199/month as an add-on or comes included with select Thinkific Plus plans.

Our honest take: Thinkific is slightly less exciting for marketers because it does not feel as funnel-native as Kajabi or as sales-simple as Teachable. But for educators, academies, and structured training brands, it remains a serious option.

Final Verdict

Kajabi vs Teachable vs Thinkific is not a one-winner comparison. Kajabi is best for serious marketers and agencies, Teachable is best for fast course selling, and Thinkific is best for structured learning businesses.

If we had to choose one platform for Affinco's audience of marketers, agencies, course creators, and digital-product sellers, we would give Kajabi the edge because it solves more of the business stack in one place. It is expensive, but it is also the only platform in this comparison that feels like a full course business operating system rather than only a course platform.

If budget is the main issue, start with Teachable. If student experience and structured learning are the main priorities, compare Thinkific carefully.

Our overall scores:

Kajabis is perfect for marketers, agencies, coaches, and premium creators
Teachable is for beginners and simple course sellers
Thinkific is for educators, academies, and structured training businesses

Sharing is Caring:-

Ali

Ali is a digital marketing expert with 7+ years of experience in SEO-optimized blogging. Skilled in reviewing SaaS tools, social media marketing, and email campaigns, we craft content that ranks well and engages audiences. Known for providing genuine information, Ali is a reliable source for businesses seeking to boost their online presence effectively.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *